Asset Allocation Matters More Than Fund Picking

advertisement

Wealthy investors frequently concentrate on identifying the “best” funds by analyzing historical returns, the experience of fund managers, and fee arrangements. However, many fail to consider a significantly more important element: asset allocation. No matter how well a fund performs, it cannot rectify a portfolio that is compromised by inadequate asset distribution, while a well-thought-out allocation can mitigate losses and enable consistent growth, irrespective of the specific performance of each fund. These often-overlooked realities highlight the importance of making allocation the foundation of your investment strategy.

image.png

It Protects You From "Sector Crashes"

A technology-driven investor might invest heavily in leading tech funds, only to suffer significant losses when the sector declines. Conversely, an investor with a diversified mix—combining technology, real estate, commodities, and bonds—will not experience a total portfolio collapse. For instance, during a recent decline in the tech sector, someone with 30% allocated to tech funds, 25% in rental property REITs, 20% in gold, and 25% in government bonds faced losses capped at 8%, while those heavily invested in tech funds saw a drop of 35%. It was the allocation strategy, rather than the quality of funds, that safeguarded them from a financial disaster.

Even top-performing fund managers may fail or exit their firms. An investor who invested 40% of their assets into a leading fund managed by a single individual experienced a sharp decline in returns when that manager retired and the replacement team altered strategies. However, an individual with a wide-ranging allocation among various asset classes—regardless of the fund managers—remained unaffected. The strategy of allocation reduces the burden of needing to select "the ideal manager" and instead enhances the resilience of your investment portfolio.

It Seizes "Growth Opportunities Across Different Assets"

Leading funds typically concentrate on a specific asset category, causing you to overlook potential profits in other areas. For example, an investor fixated on US equity funds might disregard a surge in emerging market real estate or European green energy bonds. An expansive allocation, however, guarantees exposure to growth in several sectors. During a year in which US equities rose by 5%, an allocation that comprised 20% in emerging market bonds (which increased by 12%) and 15% in renewable energy REITs (which grew by 10%) produced significantly better overall gains—without hinging on any single exceptional fund.

image.png

The choice of funds seldom considers tax implications, while allocation does. A high-net-worth individual might place tax-inefficient funds (like high-turnover equity investments) in tax-advantaged accounts and tax-efficient assets (such as municipal bonds or low-turnover index funds) in taxable accounts. This thoughtful allocation significantly reduces tax liabilities—something even the top-performing fund cannot achieve independently. Over time, paying fewer taxes translates into more wealth compounding within your portfolio.

It Adjusts to "Life's Changing Phases"

Your financial circumstances evolve—due to events like marriage, having children, or retirement—and funds cannot adapt without assistance. A younger investor may begin with a 70% stock allocation, but as retirement approaches, a prudent allocation transitions to 60% bonds and 40% stocks. This gradual adjustment safeguards wealth against market downturns late in one's career, whereas selecting new funds frequently can be both costly and risky. The process of allocation grows alongside you, while fund selection is a singular decision.

image.png

For high-net-worth investors, the illusion of the "ideal fund" consumes time and resources. Asset allocation serves as the fundamental driver of wealth—minimizing risk, enhancing returns, and corresponding with your aspirations. Cease the pursuit of the next exceptional fund; begin constructing an allocation that serves your needs.